Federal judge sends New York’s gambling case against Kalshi back to state court

A Manhattan federal judge remanded the New York attorney general's suit against Kalshi to state court on Nov. 19, rejecting Kalshi's removal arguments.

Flat illustration of a white stone column fragment beside a cream envelope with a green wax seal and a brass stopwatch, on a plain deep navy background.

New York’s enforcement case against Kalshi is headed back to state court. On Nov. 19, 2026, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the Southern District of New York granted the New York attorney general’s motion to remand and directed the clerk “to effect immediate remand to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County.” The 19-page opinion and order was entered as Doc. 25 in People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC, No. 26-CV-6550 (VSB).

The ruling ends a federal detour of almost four months. Attorney General Letitia James filed a verified petition in Manhattan state court on July 31, 2026, under Executive Law § 63(12). It brings eight causes of action: one under the New York Constitution, three under the Penal Law, three under the Racing Law and one under the federal Wire Act. Kalshi removed the case to federal court the same day. The state moved to remand on Aug. 7, Kalshi opposed on Aug. 21, and New York replied on Aug. 28.

Why the case went back

Kalshi offered two routes into federal court. The first was the federal officer removal statute. Kalshi argues that its CFTC license to operate as a designated contract market is property whose title derives from a federal officer, and that New York’s suit affects the validity of the Commodity Exchange Act. Broderick held that the suit does not affect the validity of the act, and that Kalshi’s reliance on its federal license is a defense, which cannot support removal. He also rejected Kalshi’s argument that the CFTC’s absence as a necessary party allowed removal, noting that the agency has not sought to intervene and that the remedy for a missing party is joinder in state court.

The second route was the test for state claims that turn on federal questions. Broderick found that only the Wire Act claim necessarily raises a federal issue. That issue is disputed, he held, but not substantial, because it does not go beyond applying the Wire Act to Kalshi’s conduct in New York. He called the federal-state balance “an independent reason” to remand, quoting an earlier decision that the scope of gambling laws “is clearly a matter of predominantly state concern.” Kalshi had told the court that preemption was “not [a] basis for removal here,” so the order does not decide whether federal law preempts New York’s gambling laws.

The judge denied New York’s request for attorneys’ fees, finding that Kalshi raised “colorable” arguments. He also left undecided Kalshi’s request for a protective order against an investigative subpoena that the attorney general’s Investor Protection Bureau served on Sept. 25, because a court without jurisdiction cannot rule on it.

The restraining order fight

The remand returns the case to the forum where New York first asked for emergency relief. In its notice of removal, Kalshi states that New York filed its petition “together with an application for a temporary restraining order without notice.” The attorney general’s remand brief describes the state as seeking a TRO and a preliminary and permanent injunction against what it calls an unlicensed gambling business serving bettors “in New York and elsewhere.”

Kalshi argues the requested relief would reach far beyond the state. The petition asks the court to bar Kalshi from operating a gambling business “within or from New York or to persons in New York” without a Gaming Commission license. Kalshi’s notice of removal points out that New York is its principal place of business, and its opposition brief calls the TRO application “unprecedented,” arguing that it “would effectively shut down Kalshi’s exchange nationwide.” Broderick noted that Kalshi’s briefing elsewhere says the suit seeks to “shut down Kalshi’s exchange altogether, including in states other than New York.”

The petition also seeks penalties equal to three times Kalshi’s gains, restitution and disgorgement, and $100,000 for each offer of sports wagering in New York without authorization. New York argues that Kalshi’s contracts are unlicensed gambling, and Kalshi argues they are swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. The remand order does not decide that question.

The federal fight continues on a separate track. Kalshi’s own suit against Gaming Commission officials, KalshiEX LLC v. Williams, remains on appeal at the Second Circuit (No. 26-1835) after Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction on July 7, 2026. Our case file on New York v. Kalshi tracks the earlier filings, and our guide to whether Kalshi is legal in New York covers the parallel proceedings.

The order does not decide whether Kalshi’s contracts are gambling or swaps. The state court in Manhattan, not a federal judge, will now handle New York’s request to stop Kalshi from operating “within or from New York.”

Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.