Fourth Circuit upholds denial of Kalshi’s Maryland injunction in a 2-1 ruling
The Fourth Circuit affirmed, 2-1, the denial of Kalshi's injunction against Maryland regulators, with the two judges in the majority giving different reasons.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, affirmed a Maryland federal judge’s refusal to block the state’s gaming regulators from enforcing their sports wagering laws against Kalshi’s sports event contracts. The published decision in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892, came by a 2-1 vote, more than six months after oral argument on May 7.
The ruling itself is a one-line per curiam opinion: “The judgment of the district court is AFFIRMED.” Judges Gregory and Thacker joined it, and each wrote a separate concurring opinion. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. Judge Thacker wrote that she reached the result “via a different route” than Judge Gregory, and neither judge joined the other’s opinion, so the 59-page filing carries no reasoning adopted by both.
How the case got here
Maryland’s gaming regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on April 7, 2025, ordering it to stop offering its sports contracts to Marylanders without a state sports wagering license within 15 days. Kalshi sued on April 21, 2025, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts the state’s laws as applied to trading on its federally regulated exchange. US District Judge Adam B. Abelson denied a preliminary injunction on Aug. 1, 2025, finding Kalshi unlikely to succeed on the merits. Our Maryland explainer traces that history.
Two concurrences, two routes
Judge Gregory did not decide whether Kalshi’s sports contracts are “swaps” traded on a designated exchange, which fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction. Even assuming they are, he concluded, Congress did not clearly displace Maryland’s power to regulate gambling. He read the exclusive-jurisdiction provision alongside the CEA’s Special Rule on event contracts involving gaming and the CFTC’s Rule 40.11, which says exchanges “shall not list for trading or accept for clearing” contracts that involve gaming. Kalshi’s contracts keep trading because it self-certified them and the CFTC has not ordered them removed, he wrote, and that continued trading does not by itself establish exclusive federal authority. He also pointed to the CFTC’s pending March and June 2026 rulemaking proposals on the Special Rule as signs the question remains unsettled.
He rejected conflict preemption too: Kalshi could comply with both sovereigns by getting a Maryland license or by “declining to offer the individual contracts within the state.” His conclusion: “Until Congress and the CFTC are clear, I conclude that Maryland has concurrent authority under these facts.”
Judge Thacker concurred in the judgment on a different ground. She would hold that the contracts are not swaps at all, because they pay on the outcome of a game rather than on whether an event occurs, noting that dictionaries label the sense of “event” meaning “outcome” archaic. She warned that Kalshi’s reading would make nearly every sports bet placed off a prediction market illegal under federal law. “What is happening here is sports betting,” she wrote.
The dissent
Judge Benjamin would have found the contracts to be swaps and Maryland’s laws field-preempted. She proposed limits, writing that parlays and prop bets would generally fall outside the swap definition. “Just because the CFTC hasn’t disapproved Kalshi’s sports-related contracts under its regulations, doesn’t mean Maryland can regulate Kalshi in its place,” she wrote. She did not reach Kalshi’s conflict-preemption argument. She would have vacated the order and remanded for the district court to weigh the remaining injunction factors.
Where the circuits stand
The opinions cite the other appellate decisions: the Third Circuit found preemption in New Jersey’s case, while the Sixth Circuit and the Ninth Circuit found none after concluding the contracts are not, or likely are not, swaps. The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing of its ruling on Nov. 4.
The affirmance leaves the denial of Kalshi’s preliminary injunction in place; only the dissent would have sent the case back to the district court. The opinion does not address Maryland’s August 2025 written assurance of non-enforcement, which our explainer reported was tied to the pending appeal, or what the state will do next.
Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.