New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition against Kalshi waits on a Dec. 7 response
New Jersey asks the Supreme Court to reverse Kalshi's Third Circuit win; Kalshi's brief in opposition is due Dec. 7 after two extensions.

New Jersey’s request that the U.S. Supreme Court take up its fight with Kalshi is still pending as of Nov. 19, 2026. Kalshi’s brief in opposition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX, LLC, No. 26-299, is due Dec. 7, under extensions the clerk granted on Sept. 22 and Oct. 30, according to the Supreme Court docket.
The petitioners are Mary Jo Flaherty, interim director of the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement, and Attorney General Jennifer Davenport. They filed on Sept. 2, 2026, and the case was docketed Sept. 8. The state’s Sept. 2 press release called it the first certiorari petition on whether prediction markets can offer sports contracts without following state gambling laws.
The question New Jersey wants answered
The petition presents one question: whether the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act “preempted States from regulating sports bets that occur within their jurisdictions if those bets are offered on markets registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.”
It asks the Court to review an April 6, 2026, decision of the Third Circuit. In that 2-1 ruling, Judge Porter, joined by Chief Judge Chagares, affirmed a preliminary injunction barring the Division of Gaming Enforcement from enforcing state law against Kalshi’s sports-related contracts. The majority found Kalshi had a reasonable chance of showing that its sports contracts are “swaps” under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction and that federal law preempts the state’s laws as applied to them. Judge Roth dissented, writing that New Jersey’s laws are not preempted.
New Jersey argues the ruling is wrong twice over. First, it argues that sports outcomes are not “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act, which covers contracts tied to an event “associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.” Second, it argues that even if they were swaps, the CFTC’s “exclusive jurisdiction” only divides authority among federal agencies and does not displace state gambling laws.
The petition also argues that Kalshi’s reading has consequences beyond prediction markets. Citing the Act’s limits on trading swaps off CFTC-registered markets, the state contends that treating sports bets as swaps would put state-licensed sportsbooks, including those in casinos, on the wrong side of federal law.
The split it points to
The petition’s main reason for review is a conflict with the Ninth Circuit. On Aug. 28, 2026, in Kalshi v. Assad, that court upheld the dissolution of Kalshi’s injunction against Nevada’s gaming regulators, finding Kalshi had not shown its sports contracts are likely swaps. New Jersey calls that split “direct, acknowledged, and irreconcilable” and counts at least 39 lawsuits across 20 states.
Other appeals courts have ruled since the filing. The Sixth Circuit ruled on Sept. 25 that Kalshi had not shown its sports contracts are swaps, in the Ohio and Tennessee appeals. On Nov. 17 the Fourth Circuit upheld the denial of Kalshi’s Maryland injunction by a 2-1 vote. Kalshi, for its part, asked the Ninth Circuit on Nov. 9 to put its Nevada loss on hold while it seeks Supreme Court review of that ruling.
Where the case stands
Eleven amicus briefs were filed on the docket between Sept. 22 and Oct. 8. The filers include Ohio with 38 other states and the District of Columbia, the National Football League, the American Gaming Association, 145 Indian tribes and tribal organizations, the Casino Association of New Jersey, former CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler and former Sen. Christopher Dodd.
Kalshi’s response was first due Oct. 8. Neal Katyal of Milbank asked on Sept. 18 for 30 more days, citing other professional obligations, and the clerk extended the deadline to Nov. 9. Paul Clement of Clement & Murphy then asked on Oct. 29 for 28 more days, to Dec. 7, listing other briefs and arguments on his calendar. His letter states that New Jersey did not oppose the request, and the clerk granted it Oct. 30.
A petition is a request for review, not a ruling, and the docket shows no decision by the Court on it as of Nov. 19. The docket shows no Supreme Court action on the preliminary injunction the Third Circuit affirmed.
Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.