44 attorneys general tell the CFTC its casino-style gambling carve-out rests on a false distinction

Attorneys general for 43 states and D.C. argue the CFTC's interim rule wrongly limits its gambling exclusion from the swap definition to house-backed games.

A bundle of sealed envelopes tied with a green band beside a casino chip and a closed rulebook on a navy background.

Attorneys general for 43 states and the District of Columbia have told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that its interim rule on gambling products is “arbitrary and capricious, procedurally defective, and in excess of the Commission’s statutory authority.” Their comment letter, dated Nov. 18, 2026, the last day for comments, targets “Further Definition of ‘Swap’ To Exclude Casino-Style Gambling Products” (RIN 3038-AF81), a rule that has been in effect since Oct. 19.

The letter is written on Maryland letterhead, and Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown signs first. It names Maryland, Kentucky, Ohio, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Utah and Tennessee, “and 35 other States and the District of Columbia.” The signature pages run from Alabama and California to Washington, West Virginia and Wyoming. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, who co-led the effort, announced it in a Nov. 20 release describing a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general. “The CFTC continues to stray far outside of its lane,” Davenport said.

What the interim rule does

The CFTC issued the rule on Oct. 15, and the Federal Register published it on Oct. 19 at 91 FR 65969, effective that day, with comments due Nov. 18. Chairman Michael Selig voted in favor, and no commissioner voted against.

It adds a paragraph to the swap definition in 17 CFR 1.3. A contract is not a swap if it is offered by a person licensed to offer gambling or accept wagers under state or tribal law, acting within that license, and regulated as gambling, and if it is not traded on a board of trade, an exchange, a swap execution facility or “any other market in which trades are executed multilaterally or subject to individual negotiation.” The rule names sports wagers at licensed sportsbooks, casino games and other licensed games of chance such as bingo, pool wagering, lotteries and raffles.

What the states argue

The attorneys general argue the rule draws a “false distinction” by limiting the exclusion to house-backed wagering. Many state laws, they write, reach “any system or method of wagering,” and states regulate exchange wagering, peer-to-peer betting, parimutuel pools on horse racing and percentage games such as poker, in which bettors play against each other rather than a house. The rule’s description of gambling as typically bilateral transactions with a house rests, in their reading, on a single 2004 economics paper that examined one NFL season of data from one online sportsbook.

They argue the line clashes with the CFTC’s own past positions, including Rule 40.11, the 2012 joint CFTC-SEC swap definitions and a 2024 event-contract proposal. They also cite court rulings, among them the Ninth Circuit’s rejection of Kalshi’s peer-to-peer argument in KalshiEX v. Assad as “distinctions without differences,” and a Nov. 10 Southern District of New York opinion that, in the letter’s account, criticized the interim rule directly: “Who is on the other side of the bet is simply not a difference that makes a difference.”

Because the carve-out stops at multilateral markets, the states argue, parimutuel and other bettor-against-bettor wagering offered only under state licenses could be swaps that must trade on CFTC-regulated exchanges. Under that reasoning, the letter argues, “horse racing tracks across the country are now currently operating criminal enterprises,” a result it calls absurd. It also cites a Citizens Bank report finding that almost a quarter of Kalshi’s users are under 25, compared with 7% at state-regulated sportsbooks, and a Wall Street Journal finding that 0.1% of Polymarket accounts take 67% of the profits.

On procedure, the states argue the CFTC lacked good cause to skip notice and comment, noting the rule itself states it would “not change the legal rights or obligations of market participants.” They argue a one-member commission lacks a quorum, that a footnote saying the SEC “joins” is not the joint rulemaking the statute requires, and that sharing the rule with the Federal Reserve Board is not consultation. The fix the letter points to is broader, not narrower: the agency “can maintain consistency only by expanding its exclusion to include all state-regulated gambling.”

Where it fits

The letter has a companion. That one, co-led by Ohio, opposes the CFTC’s proposal to write event contracts into the swap definition, which we covered on Nov. 19. Comments on both rules closed Nov. 18. New Jersey’s own Supreme Court petition against Kalshi was still pending as of Nov. 19.

For exchanges such as Kalshi and Polymarket, that line matters. A sports wager at a licensed sportsbook falls inside the exclusion; a contract on the same game traded on a multilateral exchange does not. The states are asking the CFTC to erase that line by treating every state-regulated wager, house-backed or not, as outside the swap definition. As of the New Jersey release on Nov. 20, the interim rule was still in effect.

Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.