Ohio leads 43 states and D.C. in urging the CFTC to withdraw its plan to define event contracts as swaps

A 44-member coalition co-led by Ohio filed a comment letter on the CFTC's swap proposal, arguing the agency lacks the power and a quorum to adopt it.

Flat illustration of a green fountain pen on a stack of cream paper beside an emerald inkwell and a brass desk stamp, against a slate-blue wall.

Attorneys general for 43 states and the District of Columbia have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw its proposal to treat sports event contracts as swaps. Their 25-page comment letter, dated Nov. 18, 2026, is addressed to CFTC Secretary Christopher Kirkpatrick and dated the day the comment period closed. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson co-led it with the attorneys general of Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Tennessee and Utah, and 35 more states and D.C. signed on.

The signers include California, Louisiana, Arkansas, Missouri, Iowa, Michigan and Massachusetts. Ohio’s news release calls the coalition bipartisan.

“A sports bet isn’t a derivative just because the CFTC says so,” Wilson said in the release. “The agency doesn’t get to invent powers that Congress never gave it, ignore federal court decisions and bulldoze state consumer protections.”

The rule at issue

The letter comments on “Further Definition of ‘Swap’-Inclusions,” a proposed rule the Federal Register published on Oct. 19, 2026, with comments due Nov. 18. It would further define “swap” to explicitly include event contracts, “including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural-, and weather-related events.” The CFTC announced the proposal on Oct. 9, as we reported, alongside an interim final rule, in effect since Oct. 19, that excludes wagers placed on sportsbooks and casino games from the swap definition.

What the states argue

The states argue that sports bets are not “commonly known to the trade as a swap,” one of the statutory tests the proposal relies on. They quote the CFTC’s own interim final rule: “[t]he Commission is unaware of any trade usage or market belief that gambling products are considered swaps in the derivatives industry.” They also argue that sports outcomes lack the link to financial consequences the statute requires, and that excluding traditional sports wagers from the swap definition in the interim rule while counting them as swaps in the proposal is a contradiction.

On procedure, the letter argues that the law lets the CFTC further define “swap” only jointly with the Securities and Exchange Commission and in consultation with the Federal Reserve Board. It says SEC participation appears only in a footnote and that only the CFTC’s secretary signed the proposal. The states also argue that the commission, which the letter describes as currently having Chairman Michael S. Selig as its only member, lacks a quorum to adopt any rule. The White House sent two CFTC nominees to the Senate on Nov. 12, as we reported.

The letter argues the rule could not apply in the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, where, the letter says, appeals courts have held that sports event contracts are not swaps, and lists the same question as pending in the Second, Seventh, Eighth and Tenth Circuits and before Massachusetts’ highest court. Even if it took effect, the states argue, it would apply only going forward, leaving them free to bring enforcement actions over sports contracts offered before then.

Age limits and self-exclusion

The letter argues that the proposal “lacks any age limits for prediction-market gambling, self-exclusion programs, licensing or evaluations to determine if the exchange is trustworthy.” It points to state rules such as New York’s 21-and-over limit and Ohio’s voluntary exclusion program, notes that Kalshi’s member agreement allows 18-year-olds, and cites a Citizens Bank industry report for the figure that almost a quarter of Kalshi’s users are under 25, compared with 7% at state-regulated sportsbooks. It also warns that licensed sportsbooks could restructure as exchanges, citing DraftKings’ prediction market.

The states propose an alternative: define swaps to cover event contracts tied to financial, economic or commercial consequences while exempting sports and casino-style contracts. A footnote adds that several signers object to including politics, elections, weather and culture contracts too. The letter asks the CFTC to “start afresh” and clarify that sports contracts are not swaps.

A comment letter is not a ruling, and as of Nov. 19 the Federal Register lists the measure as a proposed rule. The filing comes as Ohio faces federal suits from exchanges over its gambling laws, including Novig’s complaint filed Nov. 16, which relies in part on the CFTC’s October rulemaking.

Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.