Novig sues Ohio officials to block enforcement of state gambling laws against its sports contracts

Novig asked an Ohio federal court on Nov. 16 to bar state officials from enforcing gambling laws against sports contracts on its CFTC-designated exchange.

A classical columned courthouse with a large cream envelope sealed with a gold scales-of-justice wax seal resting on its front steps, in pale blue and lilac.

Novig has taken its fight with Ohio to federal court. On Nov. 16, 2026, Ludlow Exchange, LLC, which does business as Novig, filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio (No. 1:26-cv-03009), asking a judge to stop state officials from enforcing Ohio’s sports gaming and gambling laws against the sports event contracts on its exchange.

The defendants are Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, Ohio Casino Control Commission Interim Executive Director Andromeda Morrison and the commission’s seven commissioners, all sued in their official capacities. The 53-page complaint seeks a declaratory judgment and preliminary and permanent injunctions. On the docket, Novig indicated the case may be related to a pending civil action, No. 1:26-cv-02169, which the complaint cites as Underdog Exchange DCM, Inc. v. Wilson, also in the Northern District of Ohio.

The October letter

The suit responds to a cease-and-desist letter Morrison signed on Oct. 2, 2026. As quoted in the complaint, the letter asserts that “Novig is operating online sports gaming” by offering sports event contracts to people in Ohio without a sports gaming license, and is “clearly engaged in bookmaking or facilitating bookmaking.” It gave Novig 14 days to confirm in writing that it had stopped and warned of possible administrative, civil, nuisance or criminal action. The letter relied on the Sixth Circuit’s September decision in KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler, which held that Kalshi’s sports contracts are not swaps.

The commission sent letters the same day to other operators, including Polymarket US and Underdog Predict. By early November, five of the ten companies that received them had stopped offering sports event contracts in Ohio or agreed to, while Novig was one of three still “in discussions” with the regulator, as we reported.

Two claims

The CFTC designated Novig as a contract market on June 16, 2026. Its complaint brings two counts.

The first is under the Commerce Clause. Novig argues that Ohio’s licensing regime discriminates against out-of-state businesses: online sports gaming licenses go only to applicants with a place of business in Ohio or to operators working under contract with one, the server accepting wagers must sit in a secure facility in the state, and licensees may accept wagers only from people physically in Ohio. Novig is headquartered in New York and does not maintain a place of business in Ohio.

The second is preemption under the Supremacy Clause. Novig argues that its sports contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, which gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps traded on a designated contract market. It leans on the CFTC’s October rulemaking, issued Oct. 9: an interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the swap definition, and a proposed rule that would define event contracts, including sports contracts, as swaps.

The complaint offers three answers to Schuler. The ruling is not final: Kalshi’s petition for rehearing en banc is pending and three certiorari petitions on the same question are before the Supreme Court. The CFTC’s rulemaking, Novig argues, removes the premise of Schuler’s swap holding. And Schuler itself recognized that the act displaces “direct enforcement and regulatory authority pertaining to the licensing and operation of” designated contract markets, which Novig contends is exactly what the letter targets by demanding it stop “operating an FCM or DCM that offers sports event contracts to persons located in Ohio.”

What Novig puts at stake

Novig argues that complying is not a practical option. A license would require a contract with an Ohio proprietor, servers in Ohio, a market limited to people in the state and Ohio sports gaming taxes, which it argues would fragment the national liquidity an exchange depends on. The complaint lists what it faces if it keeps operating: possible felony liability, uncapped administrative penalties and nuisance abatement. It also points to the commission’s request for a $5 million penalty against KalshiEX LLC in an administrative proceeding on April 14, 2026, and to an Oct. 20 letter telling Ohio’s own licensees to stop providing services to entities offering sports event contracts in Ohio without a sports gaming license.

The complaint draws a limit around its own claim. Novig does not contend that federal law preempts Ohio’s regulation of gambling generally, and it accepts that the state remains free to license sportsbooks and casinos operating outside a designated contract market. It also recounts that its parent company, Novig, Inc., secured a Colorado sports betting license in 2023 and withdrew from that market in April 2024, an experience the complaint uses to argue that state-by-state licensing is structurally incompatible with an exchange.

The wider fight

Ohio is not the only state where Novig is in court over its sports contracts. On Nov. 10, a federal judge in Manhattan denied Novig’s bid to block New York, finding its contracts likely are not swaps. A day earlier, Missouri filed counterclaims in Novig’s suit there, seeking to cut off its payments from state residents.

The complaint states that Novig offers event contracts to customers in Ohio, including in Cleveland and Akron. As of the evening of Nov. 16, the Ohio docket showed only the complaint: no motion for a preliminary injunction had been filed and no judge had ruled. The preemption claim turns largely on whether sports event contracts on a CFTC-designated exchange are swaps beyond state gambling law, a question on which, in the words of a Supreme Court amicus brief from Ohio and others, federal and state courts are “hopelessly confused and divided.”

Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.