CFTC renews its emergency bid to restrain New York as the state moves against Kalshi

The CFTC refiled its July request for a temporary restraining order against New York, and Judge Schofield set a same-day phone conference.

Flat illustration of a black desk telephone beside a grey legal folder and a small brass stopwatch, on a plain deep navy background.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission went back to federal court on Nov. 20, 2026, with an emergency motion for a temporary restraining order against the State of New York. The docket in United States of America v. State of New York (S.D.N.Y., No. 1:26-cv-03404) lists the filing as Dkt. 186, a “Renewed Motion Originally filed as Dkt. No. 118,” with a return date of 3:00 p.m. that day.

The motion attaches one exhibit: an exhibit the docket describes as a “Proposed Temporary Restraining Order Filed by New York in State Court.” The motion itself is not yet public on CourtListener, so this account of what the CFTC wants rests on the docket text and the July motion it renews.

Judge Lorna G. Schofield responded the same day by scheduling a conference. In a short order signed Nov. 20 (Dkt. 187), she directed the parties to appear for a telephonic conference at 5:00 p.m. As of about 6:10 p.m. ET, the docket showed no entry after that order, and no ruling on the motion.

What the CFTC asked for in July

The CFTC and the United States first sought a temporary restraining order on July 30, 2026 (Dkt. 118). Their memorandum (Dkt. 119) argued that New York’s “increasingly aggressive attempts to assert jurisdiction” intrude on the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction under the Commodity Exchange Act. It pointed to a deadline: New York had agreed not to take enforcement action against Kalshi only “up to and including July 30, 2026.”

The federal plaintiffs argued that event contracts offered on CFTC-regulated exchanges, including those tied to sports, are “swaps” under the act, so state gambling law is preempted. They also warned that New York enforcement could force exchanges to unwind trades, and they cited the CFTC’s July 14 order directing Kalshi to fulfill open trades involving Michigan residents. The memorandum said the largest prediction-market operators, including Kalshi, Polymarket US and Gemini, are headquartered in New York and argued that a state order could shut down their operations nationwide.

The request did not succeed then. Judge Jed S. Rakoff, sitting in the emergency Part I because the assigned judge was unavailable, heard argument on July 31. His written order (Dkt. 121) describes the motion as seeking to stop New York “from moving forward with their very recently filed case against KalshiEX, LLC” until the preliminary injunction motion was decided. He denied it from the bench, finding no showing of a high likelihood of success on the merits or of likely irreparable harm, but left the plaintiffs free to renew it. The case was reassigned to Judge Schofield on Aug. 5.

The case behind the motion

The United States and the CFTC sued New York, Gov. Kathy Hochul, Attorney General Letitia James and the New York State Gaming Commission, its executive director and its commissioners on April 24, 2026. The complaint followed New York’s April 21 enforcement suits against Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan and a Gaming Commission cease-and-desist letter to Kalshi in October 2025. It brings two counts, claiming that New York’s sports wagering law (Racing Law § 1367) and its Penal Law gambling offenses are preempted as applied to transactions on CFTC-designated contract markets. It asks for a declaration to that effect and a permanent injunction against enforcing those laws against such transactions.

The federal plaintiffs moved for a preliminary injunction on May 1 (Dkt. 34). Coinbase and Gemini filed briefs supporting it, and the American Gaming Association filed one opposing it. Since then, both sides have filed a stream of supplemental authority notices: the CFTC on an interim final rule and a notice of proposed rulemaking in October, and New York on the Second Circuit’s Nov. 3 order and, on Nov. 18, an opinion in Kalshi v. Martin. The docket lists no ruling on the preliminary injunction motion as of Nov. 20.

The state-court backdrop

The renewed motion arrived a day after a federal judge sent New York’s gambling case against Kalshi back to state court, and on the same day the attorney general asked a Manhattan state judge to restrain Kalshi. On Nov. 3, the Second Circuit denied Kalshi an injunction pending appeal in its own suit against New York officials.

New York argues that the contracts are unlicensed gambling under state law. The CFTC argues that they are swaps under its exclusive federal jurisdiction. No court in this case has decided that question, and in the records opened for this story no court had ruled on the renewed federal request or on New York’s state-court request as of Nov. 20.

Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.