Tribes, casino groups and prediction markets split as the CFTC’s swap-definition comment period closes
The CFTC's plan to define event contracts as swaps drew 140 public comments, with tribal groups opposed and Kalshi and Polymarket US in support.

The public comment period on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s plan to write event contracts into the legal definition of “swap” has closed. Comments on the proposal, “Further Definition of ‘Swap’—Inclusions” (RIN 3038-AF82), were due Nov. 18, 2026. As of 12:11 p.m. ET, Nov. 19, 2026, the regulations.gov docket (CFTC-2026-2213) showed 140 comments published, 84 of them posted on Nov. 19.
The proposal, published in the Federal Register on Oct. 19 at 91 FR 66022, would add one line to the swap definition in 17 CFR 1.3: “Event contracts, including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural, and weather-related events.” The commission issued it on Oct. 15, with Chairman Selig voting in favor and no commissioner voting against. It points to “widespread confusion and disuniformity,” citing the Third Circuit’s April 2026 ruling treating sports event contracts as swaps and the Ninth (August 2026) and Sixth (September 2026) Circuits’ contrary rulings. A companion interim final rule, in a separate docket, excludes casino-style gambling products from the definition.
Gambling Insider reported the 140 total on Nov. 19 and noted that the CFTC’s April advance notice on prediction markets drew more than 3,500 comments and its July proposal more than 1,400.
Tribal names fill much of the list. More than 40 of the 140 entries carry the name of a tribal government, a tribal gaming commission or an intertribal group, among them the National Congress of American Indians, the United South and Eastern Tribes Sovereignty Protection Fund, the National Tribal Gaming Commissioners & Regulators, and Indian gaming associations from California, Arizona, Oklahoma, Minnesota and Washington.
The list also includes the American Gaming Association, Boyd Gaming, the Nevada Resort Association, the State of Utah, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners and Better Markets. Prediction-market and financial firms on it include Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Cboe Global Markets, Gemini, Novig, Underdog, Cantor Fitzgerald, Andreessen Horowitz and the Coalition for Prediction Markets. Some filers appear more than once: BetEx has three entries and Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town two. The comment from Ohio, 42 other states and D.C. is also in the record; we covered it separately.
The case against
NCAI, which says it represents about 300 tribal nations, urges the CFTC to withdraw the proposal. “Simply labeling these wagers as swaps does not change their underlying nature as gambling,” its Nov. 18 letter reads. NCAI argues that the rule exceeds the authority the Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC and would “upend the carefully crafted regulatory balance” of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. It asks for government-to-government consultation with tribes before the rulemaking goes further and reserves the right to challenge a final rule in court.
The AGA argues that “sports event contracts are sports betting.” It asks the commission to withdraw the proposal’s inclusion of sports event contracts and to rescind the casino-style exclusion. It also disputes the proposal’s market figures. The proposal puts average monthly event-contract trading volume in August 2026 at about $1.5 billion across reporting exchanges; the AGA cites TickerTracker figures of about $40.0 billion for Kalshi and $3.8 billion for Polymarket US that month, and asks the agency to “explain and reconcile the volume discrepancy.”
The case for
Kalshi “strongly supports the prompt adoption” of the proposal and the companion rule. Its letter, signed by chief compliance officer Sudhir Jain, argues that Congress let the CFTC and the SEC settle the question “at the level of the category” rather than game by game. It proposes a definition of “event contract” limited to contracts traded on a designated contract market, an organized exchange, a swap execution facility or another multilateral market.
Polymarket US, filing as QCX LLC and QC Clearing LLC, urges adoption and argues that state-by-state limits and geofencing fragment liquidity. “Those restrictions can widen spreads, degrade price discovery, and undermine the utility of the contracts,” its letter reads. The Coalition for Prediction Markets backs both rules and asks the CFTC to keep the proposal’s list of event types “non-exhaustive” in the final rule.
Not every tribe is opposed. Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town supports both actions, arguing that IGRA and the Commodity Exchange Act “govern different activities, by different persons, under different regimes.” It asks that each final rule state that nothing in it alters IGRA, tribal-state compacts or tribal jurisdiction over gaming on Indian lands.
What comes next
A comment is not a ruling. The proposal itself asks whether event contracts are swaps; the commenters frame the stakes more broadly, as whether sports, politics, culture and weather contracts on federally registered exchanges sit under one federal regime or under the state and tribal gaming laws the opponents invoke. Background on the October proposal is in our earlier report.
Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.