Coinbase asks the CFTC to adopt the agency’s event-contract swap rule swiftly and keep the list of categories open
Coinbase's Nov. 18 letter backs the CFTC's plan to define event contracts as swaps and asks it to keep the named categories open-ended.

Coinbase has asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to adopt its proposal to write event contracts into the legal definition of “swap,” and to do it quickly. The company “strongly supports the Proposal and encourages its swift adoption,” its seven-page comment letter reads. The letter is dated Nov. 18, 2026, the day the comment period closed, and was posted to the regulations.gov docket on Nov. 19 as comment CFTC-2026-2213-0080.
Julia Hueckel, Coinbase’s director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, director and associate general counsel for institutional legal, signed it.
The proposal, “Further Definition of ‘Swap’ — Inclusions” (RIN 3038-AF82), appeared in the Federal Register on Oct. 19 at 91 FR 66022. It would further define “swap” to explicitly include event contracts, “including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural-, and weather-related events.” Background on the October proposal is in our earlier report.
The letter describes Coinbase as the owner of Coinbase Derivatives, LLC, a CFTC-registered designated contract market, and of Coinbase Financial Markets, Inc., a CFTC-registered futures commission merchant through which it offers customers nationwide access to event contracts listed on a CFTC-registered exchange. It adds that Coinbase recently registered Coinbase Clearing LLC as a derivatives clearing organization.
What Coinbase argues
Coinbase argues that the rule would confirm the Commodity Exchange Act rather than change it: event contracts that meet the statute’s definition of swap “are swaps.” The definition reaches contracts whose payment depends on an event “associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.” In Coinbase’s reading, the consequence need only be potential, and the statute does not require it to be inherent in, or embedded within, the event itself.
The company points to the “weather swaps” and “emissions swaps” Congress named in the statute, and to the act’s Special Rule, which, the letter says, “expressly empowers” the CFTC to regulate contracts based on “terrorism,” “assassination” or “gaming,” to argue that Congress did not limit swaps to events with “embedded” financial consequences. It cites the Sixth Circuit’s September ruling in KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler as the contrary view.
It also argues there is “no sound textual basis” for treating an event’s outcome differently from its occurrence. A contract on whether a team wins a championship, the letter argues, depends on an event “just as surely as a contract asking whether a hurricane makes landfall.”
The letter takes each named category in turn. It cites the D.C. Circuit’s 2024 decision in KalshiEX LLC v. CFTC for political contracts and the act’s own reference to weather swaps, and points to the commercial stakes in sports (ticketing, media rights, sponsorships) and culture (film, music and awards, which it says affect advertising, licensing and tourism). Coinbase argues that treating exchange-traded event contracts as swaps “does not collapse the distinction” between prediction markets and casino-style gambling. It describes event-contract exchanges as neutral marketplaces that match buyers and sellers, while traditional sportsbooks and casinos generally stand on the other side of a customer’s wager.
What Coinbase wants in the final rule
The letter’s requests for the final rule start with the list. It asks the commission to keep the four categories as non-exhaustive examples, retaining the “including” wording and stating in the preamble that the list is not a closed set and creates no presumption against other categories. Coinbase argues a closed list would invite “negative inferences” about unnamed products, and it names event contracts tied to digital assets, economic and business developments, technology and science as ones it wants evaluated under the same statutory framework.
It also asks the commission to affirm in the adopting release that the rule confirms the existing statutory definition, rather than suggesting sports, political, cultural or weather contracts become swaps only on its effective date.
And it asks the commission to state that it is both adopting the best reading of the statute and using its delegated power to “further define” swap. Coinbase also invites the agency to explain that the rule’s benefits outweigh its costs even if a court found the baseline to be states regulating sports and other event contracts.
The letter argues that conflicting court rulings “reduce customer goodwill, fracture market depth and liquidity,” and risk impeding hedging by traders who still have access to the market.
A companion letter
The same two signers sent a second letter, also dated Nov. 18, backing the CFTC’s interim final rule (RIN 3038-AF81) that excludes casino-style gambling products from the swap definition. “Prediction markets are derivatives markets,” its introduction begins. In it, Coinbase argues that the federal court in Manhattan “erred” in Novig v. James when it declined to adopt the interim rule’s analysis. The Block reported both letters on Nov. 19.
Where the docket stands
As of early Nov. 20, the docket listed 140 comments. Kalshi, Polymarket US and the Coalition for Prediction Markets also back the proposal, while the National Congress of American Indians urges withdrawal and the American Gaming Association asks the agency to drop sports contracts from it, as we reported. Attorneys general for 43 states and D.C. asked the CFTC to withdraw the plan. A comment letter is not a ruling, and the Federal Register still lists the measure as a proposed rule.
Our AI news desk researched and wrote this article, and software checked every factual sentence against the records it links to, following the WriterOps methodology. Report an error.